A prison can be thought
of mostly as a men's center. More precisely, a center for fatherless
men. John Allen Muhammad and John Lee Malvo, the D.C. area sniper
suspects- both raised without their biological dads-are among the
latest additions.
Children raised without their biological dad are more likely to join
the military at an early age, as did John Allen Muhammad. They are
more likely to have temper tantrums; Muhammad was known for temper
tantrums. And they are more likely to commit homicide and suicide.
Both Johns have, in essence, it appears, done both.
We associate crime with poverty, but a boy or girl raised without
a biological dad is more likely to become a criminal than a child
growing up in poverty. "Biological" is key. During 13
years of research for Father and Child Reunion, I discovered,
although I am a step dad and not a biological dad, that step dads
do not seem to fill the void experienced by so many children who have
little or no contact with their biological dad. John Malvo had a quasi-step
dad figure in John Muhammad-but no contact with his biological dad.
Children raised without their biological fathers are more vulnerable
to being recruited by a strong substitute dad-be it a gang, cult,
religion or a final solution. When Nazis sought young recruits they
sought boys raised without dads-especially those raised by dominant
and protective moms. Both John Allen Muhammad and John Lee Malvo were
vulnerable to being recruited by the strong cause of a religion, and,
in Malvo's case, the strong leadership of Muhammad.
When these vulnerabilities are magnified by child custody battles
and divorce wars, and especially the vulnerability of masculinity-after-divorce,
have gasoline near a match. The strength of masculinity-after-divorce
is a façade. After divorce men are ten times as likely as women
to commit suicide. Men's weakness is their façade of strength;
women's strength is their façade of weakness.
Women's biggest fear after divorce is economic deprivation;
men's biggest fear is emotional deprivation. The law attempts
to help women reduce their economic fear, but does not help dad reduce
his emotional fear. Instead, it exacerbates it: the legal bias toward
children being with their mom increases a dad's feelings of emotional
desertion and uselessness. Muhammad's biological son, Lindbergh Williams,
now 20, identified the two experiences he felt were so stressful to
Muhammad that it caused him to "just snap": the military and
Muhammad's loss of his children.
A man without someone to love after divorce has the four ingredients
most likely to make him prone to suicide: the feelings that no one
loves him; that no one needs him; that there's no hope of that changing,
and the inability to express those feelings. A man prepared to commit
suicide is a man with nothing to lose by committing homicide.
If he is angry with someone he can find, he has someone to
kill. If he cannot find his particular source of anger, he gets less
particular.
John Allen Muhammad was just such a man. According to John Mills,
the Tacoma attorney who represented Muhammad in his custody battle
with his ex-wife Mildred, Muhammad had heard Mildred had fled from
Tacoma to Maryland with the children. Muhammad was trying to track
her down to serve her court papers so he could also be with his children.
He had been trying to find them for more than a year. Doubtless
the frustration and anger finally exploded.
Obviously the solution is not to let men like this have their
children-it is to prevent our sons from becoming men like this. After
divorce, the process starts with doing everything legally possible
to have children raised by both their dads and their moms.
Even after divorce,
children who are most emotionally stable are ones with about equal
contact with both parents. Children do best when they are exposed
to both of their parents about equally, even when one of the parents
is considerably imperfect (the exceptions are child endangerment and
consistent bad-mouthing of the absent parent).
Why? Growing up is about discovering oneself, and the child's self
is both of its parents. Children who have only one parent after
divorce seem to feel rudderless-as if they are in search of the other
half of themselves. They act out by being anti-social, bullying
and being bullied, being aggressive, overly sensitive to criticism,
doing worse in school in every academic subject, being sick more often-in
brief, doing worse on all twenty-five of the major areas of measurement:
academic, social, psychological and physical health.
The immediate solution for Muhammad and Malvo, if convicted, is prison
or death. One way to prevent such snipers of the future is for society
to encourage the father involvement that creates more emotionally
stable children. These children will in turn become more emotionally
stable parents who can put their energy into raising children, rather
than divert energy and, in the case of men, catalyze anger by fighting
just to be a father.